Crime Salad

• Finding Tracy Hill | Columbiana County, Ohio

  In 2001, Tracy Hill was 24 years old, a college student, and separated from her husband. She was trying to build a future for herself when, suddenly, she went missing. What followed was a desperate search, suspicions of foul play, and a case that—after more than two decades—remains unsolved. Even with all the years that have passed, Tracy’s case is still open. Foul play is suspected, but without Tracy, there’s no way to bring justice to those responsible.  The Columbiana County Sheriff’s Office continues to ask for the public’s help. If you know anything about the disappearance of Tracy Hill, no matter how small, you’re urged to call their office at 330-424-7255.  Thanks Miracle Made for sponsoring this episode: Try Miracle Made sheets today at trymiracle.com/CRIMESALAD! Save over 40%, plus use promo code CRIMESALAD at checkout to get a FREE 3-piece towel set and an extra 20% off! Keywords: Tracy Hill, Guilford Lake, Columbiana County, Ohio missing persons, Kent State student disappearance, North Lima Ohio, Ohio cold cases.

  --------  

  37:34

  --------

  37:34
• STACEY B. COLBERT: THE NEVER ENDING FIGHT

  In March of 1998, 23-year-old Stacey Colbert disappeared from her Columbus, Ohio apartment. Stacey was vibrant, funny, and deeply loved by her family and friends. She had a smile that could brighten even the darkest room, and a spirit that made people want to be near her. But when she vanished, a wave of fear and unanswered questions consumed her community. What followed were years of rumors, false leads, and painful uncertainty. Stacey’s story reveals how someone can disappear even in a place that should feel safe—and how a family can be left waiting for justice that never seems to come. Helpful Links: Finishing Stacey’s Fight Facebook The family’s GoFundMe If you have any information about Stacey’s case—no matter how small—you can reach out in the following ways: 📞 Call the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office at 740-833-2800 📧 Email: [email protected] 🕵️ Submit an anonymous tip through the Ohio Attorney General’s official page: Link Check out this amazing podcast: https://www.truthandjusticepod.com/

  --------  

  38:22

  --------

  38:22
• The Murder of Jennifer Daugherty (The Greensburg Six Case)

  On a snowy morning in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, a school worker made a puzzling discovery outside Greensburg Salem Middle School—a heavy garbage can lodged beneath his truck. What he found inside would unravel one of the most shocking cases in Westmoreland County history. In this episode of Crime Salad, we uncover the disturbing story of Jennifer Daugherty and the horrifying secrets that shook a quiet Pennsylvania town. Merch and other stuff: Crimesaladpodcast.com Sponsors for this episode:  The best blanket ever!  LolaBlankets.com code CRIMESALAD for 35% off. Trust us—once you try Lola, those old throw blankets don’t stand a chance. 💚Get 30% off your first order at cornbreadhemp.com/CRIMESALAD with code CRIMESALAD

  --------  

  45:02

  --------

  45:02
• The Mysterious Death of Deborah Waggoner: South Greensburg’s 1990 Unsolved Homicide

  On the night of April 17th in 1990, Deborah Waggoner had what seemed like an ordinary plan. Around 7 PM, she left her South Greensburg home in her faded green 1976 Chevrolet Malibu. She told her boyfriend, Charles Stader, that she was headed to the nearby coin-operated Carbon Car Wash to clean her car. It was close by, so Charles didn’t expect her to be gone for more than an hour. Before she left, he’d asked her to grab a pack of cigarettes on her way home, and she agreed. That was the last time anyone saw Deborah alive. If you have any information about the muder of Deborah Waggoner, no matter how small it may seem, you can reach out to PSP Tips at (800) 472-8477, [email protected], or visit their Facebook page dedicated to sharing updates and gathering information.  Check out our webiste Ricky put togheter: crimesaladpodcast.com!! Get some merch and support our show. We hope to see you at CRIMECON NEXT WEEK! 🎉 New Customer Offer Get your 3-month Unlimited Wireless Plan for just $15 a month at mintmobile.com/CRIMESALAD ✨ Exclusive Listener Deal ● Get 25% Off @goPure with code CRIMESALAD → gopure.com #goPurepod 

  --------  

  39:34

  --------

  39:34
• Neglect and Abandonment: Mother Leaves 16-Month-Old Jailyn Candelario Alone to Die | Cleveland, Ohio

  On West 97th Street in Cleveland, Ohio, tragedy struck when police discovered 16-month-old Jailyn Candelario unresponsive inside her Pack ‘N Play. First responders tried to save her, but it was too late—Jailyn was pronounced dead at the scene. What officers found inside the home was deeply disturbing, and the condition of both the residence and the toddler immediately raised red flags for investigators. This was no tragic accident. Warning: The details that follow about Jailyn’s condition are deeply unsettling. Behind every headline and police report is a little girl who deserved love, safety, and care. Jailyn Candelario’s short life ended far too soon, and those who knew her will forever carry the weight of knowing she did not receive the protection she needed. Voice your thoughts:If you could say one thing to Jailyn today, what would it be? This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Talk it out with BetterHelp. Get 10% off your first month when you sign up at BetterHelp.com/CRIMESALAD.

  --------  

  44:32

  --------

  44:32

More True Crime podcasts

Trending True Crime podcasts

About Crime Salad

Crime Salad: Podcasts in Family