Today, Iām sharing my conversation with Greg Epstein, American Humanist chaplain at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and author of the great new book Tech Agnostic: How Technology Became the Worldās Most Powerful Religion, and Why It Desperately Needs a Reformation. We discuss:* How tech is becoming a religion, and why itās connected to our belief that weāre never enough.* How Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg, Jeff Bezos, and Bill Gates are hungry ghosts. * What ātech-as-religionā allows us to see and understand that ācapitalism-as-religionā doesnāt.* My concerns with the metaphor and Gregās thoughtful response.* How we might usher in a tech reformation, and the tech humanists leading the way.* The value of agnosticism and not-knowing when it comes to tech.Okay, thatās it for now,Charley This is a public episode. If youād like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe
-------- Ā
42:37
Can we democratize AI?
Today, Iām sharing my conversation with Divya Siddarth, Co-Founder and Executive Director of the Collective Intelligence Project (CIP) about how we might democratize the development and governance of AI. We discuss:* The CIPās work on alignment assemblies with Anthropic and OpenAI ā what theyāve learned, and why in the world a company would agree to increasing public participation.* The #1 risk of AI as ranked by the public. (Sneak peek: it has nothing to do with rogue robots.)* Are participatory processes good enough to bind companies to the decisions they generate? * How we need to fundamentally change our conception of āAI expertise.ā* How worker and public participation can shift the short-term thinking and incentives driving corporate America.* Should AI companies become direct democracies or representative ones? * How Divya would structure public participation if she had a blank sheet of paper and if AI companies had to adopt the recommendations.Thatās it for now,Charley This is a public episode. If youād like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe
-------- Ā
35:29
Building healthy local communities online & off
Today, Iām sharing my conversation with Deepti Doshi, Co-Director of New_Public about what theyāve learned building local healthy communities, online and off. We discuss:* The problem New_Public is trying to address with their initiative, Local Lab. (Which I highlighted in my recent essay, āFragment the media! Embrace the shards!ā)* What Deepti has learned about what makes for pro-social conversations that build community on messaging boards and private groups.* Why itās an oxymoron to call Twitter a āglobal town squareā and the relationship between scale and trustworthy information ecosystems.* The importance of ādigital stewardsā in facilitating online community.* How the social capital people build online is translating into IRL actions and civic engagement.* What a future might look like if New_Public realizes the vision of Local Lab.Thatās it for now,Charley This is a public episode. If youād like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe
-------- Ā
29:55
Block, build, be
This week, Iām sharing my conversation with Anya Kamenetz, the creator of The Golden Hour, a newsletter about āthriving and caring for others on a rapidly changing planet. Anya and I announced a new partnership recently ā now, when you sign up for an annual paid subscription to Untangled, youāll get free access to the paid version of The Golden Hour ā and we wanted to talk about it, and the work ahead.Along the way, we also discuss:* How weāre adapting our newsletters in response to the election.* Why mitigating harms isnāt sufficient, and a framework that can help us all orient to the present moment: block, build, be.* How we consume information ā our mindsets, habits, and practices ā and also, why āconsumeā isnāt the right frame. * The difference between social media connections and email-based relationships.* How to talk to your kids about the election.* The fragmentation of the news media environment and why itās a good thing.I couldnāt be more excited to partner with Anya and introduce you to her work. Enjoy!More soon,Charley This is a public episode. If youād like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe
-------- Ā
31:36
Is AI snake oil?
Hi, Iām Charley, and this is Untangled, a newsletter aboutĀ our sociotechnical world, and how to change it.* Come work with me!Ā The initiative I lead at Data & Society is hiring for a Community Manager.Ā Learn more here.* Check out my new course, Sociotechnical Systems Change in Practice.Ā The first cohort will take place on January 11 and 12, and you can sign up here.* Last week I interviewed Mozillaās Jasmine Sun and Nik Marda on the potential of public AI, and the week prior I shared my conversation with AI reporter Karen Hao on OpenAIās mythology, Metaās secret, and Microsoftās hypocrisy.šØĀ This is your last chance to get Untangled 40 percent off. Even better, I partnered withĀ Anya KamenetzĀ to offer you her great newsletter The Golden Hour for free!Ā Signing up for Untangled right now means youāll get $140 in value for $54.On to the show!This week I spoke with Arvind Narayanan, professor of computer science at Princeton University and director of its Center for Information Technology Policy. I spoke with Arvind about his great new book with Sayash Kapoor, AI Snake Oil: What Artificial Intelligence Can Do, What it Canāt, and How to Tell the Difference. We discuss:* The difference between generative AI and predictive AI, and why weāre both more concerned by the latter.* Whether generative AI systems can āunderstandā and āreason.ā* The difference between intelligence and power and why Arvind isnāt so concerned by the supposed existential threats of AI.* Why artificial intelligence appeals to broken institutions.* How Arvind would change AI discourse.* How technical and social experts misunderstand one another.* What a Trump second term means for AI regulation.* What excites Arvind about how his children will experience new technologies, and what makes him nervous.More soon,Charley This is a public episode. If youād like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit untangled.substack.com/subscribe