350 episodes
- In this Meaningful Money Q&A, Pete Matthew and Roger Weeks answer listener questions on UK personal finance, pensions and investing. They discuss why spending on small things can feel difficult, managing your own finances in retirement, and whether a 5% pension withdrawal rate with guardrails could work. They also explore State Pension tax and moving private pensions into ISAs, plus investing, buying a first home and repaying student loans. Finally, they consider how to balance saving for a home and a pension when starting again after divorce.
Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA64
02:18 Question 1
Hi Pete and Roger,
As always, thank you for all your great content. I hope you realise just how much you've helped so many people. The gift of sorting out your finances isn't just the practical benefit, but the peace of mind that comes with doing so, so thank you.
I'd love to hear your thoughts about why spending money on small things is so difficult. I'm 31, and am fortunate to have most things in place with my finances. For large purchases like holidays, cars etc I plan and budget appropriately, and don't mind spending generously on these.
But I feel a disproportionate amount of stress about not wasting money on more trivial things. I worry about the rising cost of fruit in the supermarket. I buy in bulk to save pennies on basic items. My old Airpods are half-broken, but the right ear just about works okay, and so I can't bring myself to spend the £200 to replace them.
My rational brain knows all of this is unnecessary. I know I could just spend the money and not have to think about these things.
I hear of similar stories from people in retirement struggling to pivot to decumulation. Why is this, and how can we think about things differently to take a more rational approach to more 'low-level' spending?
All the best,
James
11:03 Question 2
Hi Pete and Roger,
I'm in my early 30's and genuinely enjoy all aspects of personal finance. I'm the sort of person who is comfortable with spreadsheets and so tend to model a lot of my finances this way.
Over many years of listening to the podcast I've gained an appreciation for the scenarios and situations where professional advice can be invaluable.
At the same time, I really appreciate that Pete has built Meaningful Money around the idea that you can do this stuff for yourself, provided you're willing to put in the time and effort.
I wanted to know your thoughts on how you think this translates into retirement.
For those that genuinely enjoy managing their own finances do you think there are meaningful risks with continuing this self managed approach into retirement?
For example, managing a large pension pot in drawdown and planning withdrawal strategies may become more difficult in the later years depending on health.
Do either of you intend to manage your finances independently in retirement? I'd be really interested to understand your own thought processes.
Thanks for everything you do and keep up the great work.
Zak
18:14 Question 3
Hi Pete and Roger,
Thankyou both for creating this excellent podcast which has been instrumental in improving my financial knowledge and getting me to what I now consider to be financially independent.
The Meaningful Money Podcast is the podcast that I look out for first each week, and consume as soon as it is available. There are not many podcasts that are uniquely tailored to UK listeners in this space, so you provide an invaluable resource to listeners like me, which is much appreciated.
I aim to retire in March 2027 (at the end of the current tax tear), when I will be 57 years old. My question is around safe withdrawal rates. Most people are aware of the 4% rule, which has the premise that retirees can withdraw 4% of their portfolio on retirement, increase by inflation each year, and be more or less certain to not run out of money over a 30 year period (based on historical data). The downside of the 4% rule is that it often leaves a significant amount of money on the table on death.
I would like to increase my starting rate to 5%, but build in some simple guardrails to counter sequence of return risk, should the initial market performance prove to be a problem in the early years. My proposed guardrails are as follows:
- No inflationary increase in down years (when portfolio value is down on prior year balance)
- Inflationary increase to be calculated using CPI not RPI (which is typically lower and be more applicable to my circumstances due to mortgage having been paid in full)
- Inflation increase capped at 5% (so do not increase beyond 5% in years of high inflation)
- Reduce withdrawal amount by 10% in years where portfolio reduces by > 20% (in that year only). In following year the withdrawal amount returns to previous amount (unless portfolio balance falls by another 20%)
- Full state pension will be available at age 67, so can reduce drawdown by state pension amount at that time (this will reduce my drawdown from retirement pot to approx 4.4%, based on current pension amounts)
- No inflationary increases after age 75 due to expected slow-go/no-go years
- Retirement pot will be invested on a 60/40 basis, using mainly low cost passive global tracker funds, and contain a minimum of 2 years of cash in the 40 portion to use to counter bad sequence of returns in early years, if needed.
I have put the above scenario through a couple of the readily available AI tools, and they have indicated that my plan has a very high probability of success. I understand that you cannot give financial advice on the podcast but would love to get your views on how I am approaching this, and whether this approach is consistent with how you have seen this undertaken in the real world by your clients.
Thanks again for the excellent podcast, and I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this.
Colin
25:23 Question 4
Hi Pete and Roger,
I have been a loyal listener of your podcast for over five years and look forward to every new episode.
I am writing with a question on behalf of my parents. Both my mother (70) and father (73) receive the full state pension alongside very small private pensions. I recall the government mentioning that if the state pension exceeds the personal tax allowance—which is expected in the 27/28 tax year—it would not be taxed if it were an individual's only source of income. However, I have been unable to find official guidance on this.
Do you know if this is correct? If so, would it be a good idea for my parents to withdraw their remaining private pensions this tax year (£12,000 for my father and £25,000 for my mother) and move the funds into an ISA to avoid future tax?
Their current withdrawal requirement is approximately £5,000 per year combined for holidays and emergencies, meaning these funds would likely last another seven to eight years. After that, they will rely solely on the state pension. They also own their home and have the option to downsize in the future if necessary.
Thank you for your thoughts.
Kind regards,
Louise
30:43 Question 5
Hi Roger and Pete,
I've been listening to the podcast for just under a year now on my way to work, and I think I've finally caught up with every episode. Sadly, I've never ventured onto your YouTube channel for fear that both of you might be far too dashingly good-looking for me ever to concentrate on what you're saying. Your podcast never fails to make me chuckle, although I'm not entirely sure what that says about my character at the ripe old age of 22.
As the Simon & Garfunkel of the financial world, I was hoping you could share your thoughts on whether I'm heading in the right direction financially.
I have been working for just under a year after graduating from university with a degree that has absolutely nothing to do with my current job. I'm still living at home, which means no rent, no bills, and free food. The plan is to move out in around 18 months once I've completed the professional qualification for my job.
The downside is that I'm earning close to minimum wage.
I recently cashed in the Premium Bonds I've had since birth because I felt the money could be working harder. I used £16,000 to fill my Stocks & Shares ISA with accumulating global equity index funds and invested around the same amount into a GIA with the same investment strategy. My parents also contribute £4,000 each year into my Lifetime ISA.
My current plan is to invest £1,000 into the GIA each month, cover my spending, and put anything left over into a high-interest savings account as my emergency fund, while also retaining a few Premium Bonds for the love of the game. At the end of each tax year, I plan to bed and ISA as much of the GIA as possible, rinse and repeat, and pray I don't end up with a capital gains tax bill.
I also have a SIPP that my parents started for me. It's currently invested 80% in equity ETFs and 20% in bonds, although I'm planning to switch it to 100% equities given my age. I've also changed my workplace pension from the default fund into a global equity index fund, but I'm only making the minimum contributions at the moment.
So, my questions are:
- Does my overall approach seem sensible?
- Should I prioritise increasing my workplace pension contributions through salary sacrifice, contribute more to my SIPP, or continue investing into my GIA?
- I don't really like the idea of renting—I know that's a controversial opinion—but my goal is to buy my first home as soon as possible. If I buy in around 18 months' time, I'll probably only have around £16,000 in my Lifetime ISA. Can I use both my Stocks & Shares ISA and my Lifetime ISA towards my house purchase, or is it one or the other?
- Finally, my student loan. My parents have offered to pay it off as part of their estate planning to reduce a future inheritance tax bill, but we're unsure whether that's actually the best financial decision. I'd love to hear your thoughts—not advice—on whether that seems sensible.
Sorry for the long email, but I know/hope you love these deep down.
Thank you for brightening up my drive to work every morning.
With the kindest regards,
Sean
39:15 Question 6
Hello Pete and Roger,
I love both Meaningful Money and Bank of Dad podcasts. I've learnt so much in the last year since I found you, thank you for all you do!
Like so many people, I find myself mid 40's, recently divorced. Anyone who's gone through this knows the impact of breaking up finances and starting again.
I'm now saving for my first solo ownership house from £zero, desperate to save enough for a deposit by the time I'm 50 , So I can clear the mortgage before retirement. On the side I'm trying to contribute as much as I can to pension as I know that clock is ticking too.
As more people will find themselves in that situation than ever, any focus on starting again with a shorter timeline to save, in future shows would be belting!
Thanks all!
Jonny
---
Meaningful Digest Newsletter, signup at: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/signup - Planning for vulnerable beneficiaries can mean asking different questions about the future of someone you care about. In this episode, Pete Matthew speaks with John Brenchley of Broadshield Solutions about the challenges families can face and how this kind of planning differs from a conventional approach. They discuss the risk of exploitation, the wider needs of families and John's SAFE protocol. This conversation is for education, not personal advice, and the right approach will depend on your family's circumstances.
SEND Resources - https://www.broadshield.solutions/resources
Legacy Quiz - https://www.broadshield.solutions/legacy-quiz
Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/session645 - In this episode of the Meaningful Money podcast, Pete Matthew is joined by Tom Wigan, Jacksons' Head of Operations, and Demi-Leigh Gilks, Head of Advice, to react to the Autumn Budget 2026. Recorded on Budget day itself, they work through what the Chancellor's announcements mean for UK households, savers and investors. Find out what Budget 2026 actually changes for your money, and what could you do about it.
Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/session644
Jacksons: https://jacksons.life - In this episode of the Meaningful Money podcast, Pete Matthew speaks with Tom Mathar of Aegon about how people are using artificial intelligence (AI) to make sense of their finances. They explore findings from Aegon's research, including the financial questions people ask AI, differences between age groups, and why some feel more comfortable discussing money with a chatbot than a human. Pete and Tom consider the risks of relying on AI for financial advice, from inaccurate or overly agreeable answers to letting technology make decisions, and discuss how AI can be a useful thinking partner instead. What could AI mean for the future of personal finance in the UK, and how should savers use it wisely?
Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/session643 - In this Meaningful Money Q&A, Pete Matthew and Roger Weeks answer six listener questions about UK investing, pensions and retirement planning. They explore investment fund risk ratings, funding the years before the State Pension, balancing pension saving with spending and family gifts, and how salary sacrifice, relevant UK earnings and pension carry forward work. The episode also examines how Armed Forces Early Departure Payments relate to the tax-free pension cash allowance, plus whether a £2,880 SIPP contribution could benefit a non-taxpayer approaching retirement. A practical UK personal finance podcast for anyone seeking clearer answers on investment risk, pension tax relief and making retirement income last.
Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA63
01:45 Question 1
Dear Roger, Pete and Producer Kate,
Thanks for all the work you do in producing a great podcast. In a world where financial literacy is often kept behind a paywall, the clarity and confidence your show provides is more than just 'good content'; it's a public service that is genuinely levelling the playing field for all of us.
I wondered if you could impart some of your wisdom from advising clients over the years. At my workplace I'm that guy who tries to encourage the rest of the workforce to engage with their finances. I mainly do this through an internal discussion forum, getting some external speakers in once in a while and me generally trying to signpost good information for people to go and educate themselves. Rest assured the Meaningful Money podcast is top of the bookmarks list, closely followed by Bank of Dad for younger team mates.
I've hit a situation a few times now that I feel you must have seen on countless occasions in your careers and it is to do with risk ratings for investment funds.
The situation typically plays out like this. After being convinced that they should engage with their pension, and that the default fund may not be right for them, they go and prepare to move into a 100% equity global tracker and duly read the factsheet. And then they stop. They look at the section normally entitled something like "risk rating". Using the Vanguard platform as an example (but I think most are similar) a 100% equity fund is nearly always 6 out of 7 or 7 out of 7 on the risk scale.
To the newly self-aware but nervous investor they recoil in horror. The old objections start to flood in like:
"But I'm not a gambler"
"Does high risk mean I could lose it all?"
"If a well diversified portfolio everyone says I should get is 6 or 7 what the heck is Bitcoin, day trading and all the other things I'm told to stay away from? Is this as bad as them?"
To me it seems there's a big problem with the way these ratings are presented. To my eye it would appear anything "low risk" is cash or cash like, anything in the middle is incredibly bond heavy and anything with a chance of beating inflation over a long time period is presented as very risky. It strikes me it should be reframed as maybe a "long term reward rating" or a "volatility index" because 'risk' has such an ingrained negative connotation.
I was wondering if you have any background into why these scales are presented in such an off putting manner and if you have any great ways of handling objections at the last minute based on your experience?
Thanks,
Tom
12:45 Question 2
Hello Pete and Roger,
Love the show and the invaluable insights you provide on a weekly basis, keep up the good work!
I am 55 & my wife is 54 both hoping to retire when I turn 60. No children, so no big inheritance concerns.
I am in the LGPS Scotland pension scheme and projections at 60 suggest I will receive roughly £19k pa + a tax-free lump sum of around £50k.
My wife is in the NHS Scotland pension scheme and her projections suggest an annual pension of circa £9k with a tax-free lump sum of £15k.
I have been paying the maximum amount under salary sacrifice to the LGPS AVC scheme since we became mortgage free so there should be a minimum of £90k in that pot which I intend to take as a tax-free lump sum.
We are hoping to downsize from our current house once we finish working into something smaller & more retirement friendly and believe this will realise equity of around £100k.
We think we can live well off circa £40k pa, but are unsure of the most efficient way to invest the lump sums, equity and AVC pots to provide the required income top up each year until we reach state pension age without overly diminishing the capital.
We want to use residual funds to allow us to over-winter in sunnier climes every year whilst our health allows. We imagine this will be our biggest spend in retirement outside of the draw down to achieve the £40k pa living allowance.
Hoping to create a buffer cash fund of circa £40k, possibly sitting in premium bonds, whilst investing the rest of the capital in GI accounts and topping up ISAs every year to the £20k threshold, to use these to withdraw tax-free funds every year thereafter.
Or is there another more efficient way to take the desired draw down every year to keep our tax bill as low as possible?
Many thanks & best wishes, Scott
16:36 Question 3
Hi Roger and Pete, and production crew - fantastic content and discussions, thank you.
I am approaching my half century milestone. I am in the fortunate position of having approx £815k in my DC pension (which I can access at 55 - protected pension age) and also a sizable stock portfolio (not in an ISA). I've noticed that annual gains in my pension now significantly outweigh my contributions - I think this might be unintentional coast fire. I have wondered what is the point of continuing high percentage salary sacrifice contributions, 30% of base pay (employee+employer) given the pension fund compounding is at least triple what I contribute. I am also in the unfortunate position of sitting in the middle of the 60% tax trap, but my pension contributions still don't bring me below £100k because quarterly stock awards (taxable event) and bonus continue to push me into the 60% tax trap again. Dividend payments from stock are approx. £5000 per year which I currently reinvest. I also have a Cash ISA and a Stocks and Share ISA.
I have two young children (early secondary school age), and I contribute monthly amounts to their Junior SIPP and Junior Stocks and Shares ISA. My wife has a DB public sector pension, having worked in education for 30+ years - she is the same age as myself.
First question - I'll likely need to speak to an IFA but would also appreciate your thoughts on stopping or reducing pension contributions and maybe redirecting it for other purposes (life experiences, increasing children's JISA / JSIPP, giving to charity etc). The tax benefit of contributing to my pension is very attractive but what is the point of saving more when I likely won't need it... I am also wondering about spending money on life experiences now rather than waiting until I decide to draw on my pension. I suppose only I can answer this question but is there something I am missing?
Second question on my mind - what is the definition of "surplus income" when it comes to gifting (which I have started to think about a lot for IHT purposes)? I would like to regularly gift to my children. As a hypothetical scenario - can I just give them £500 each a month from my pension if I don't need it / it is surplus to my living needs? E.g. £4000 pm income, £3000 pm living costs, £1000 pm leftover - if I eat beans on toast I could give them a lot more. Does the same apply to stocks or dividends, can I gift them regularly and achieve the same tax benefits?
Thanks
Ben
23:07 Question 4
Hi Pete and Roger,
First of all, love the podcast and a big thank you for all the work you guys do.
My question centres around salary sacrifice and unused pension allowance.
I recently turned 55. Having been employed in the same profession for well over 30 years and reached a fairly senior position, I'm feeling burnt out, and feel I need a change of pace for the remaining years of work (either by taking a step back from my current role or a complete change in direction). Fortunately we are in a position where I can afford to take a significant reduction in salary, work for several more years whilst the pension pots continue to grow before we reach the point where we can both retire.
I currently have a salary of circa £75k and car allowance of £6k, and receive a discretionary annual bonus of circa £2k; so, a total income of around £83k. I also receive private medical insurance, which has a taxable benefit value of around £2k. In order to try and remain a basic rate taxpayer, since paying the mortgage off, I have been contributing circa 47% of my salary into my work pension via salary sacrifice. My company also contributes 6.5%.
However, whilst I would like to change direction as soon as possible, if I continue in my current role for the remainder of the current financial year, I am due to receive a significant additional bonus, which could amount to circa £50k (which likely won't be paid until the 2027/28 tax year). I therefore intend to stay and secure this bonus, putting as much of it as possible into my pension to minimise tax.
I'm aware I could potentially tap into previous years' unused allowance. However, given the pension is a salary sacrifice scheme, is this unused allowance the difference between my total taxable income (£48,250) and my total pension contribution during the year (£38,625) or the difference between the £60,000 maximum annual allowance and the total pension contributions? Clearly, over three years, this could make a substantial difference (£28,875 compared with £64,125).
Even if it is the latter, if I retain the same rate of salary sacrifice out of my (basic) salary, and my total taxable income in 2027/28 remains at, say, £48,250, then would I also be limited to this as a maximum I could contribute, this being 100% of my income (which may also have a bearing on when I choose to change role). Or would the bonus simply be classed as additional income, which would then allow me to take advantage of the unused allowance (whichever figure that may be)?
As you can probably tell, I'm a bit confused. I don't want to fall foul of the rules, so your thoughts would be most welcome!
Tim
28:27 Question 5
Hi Nick, Rog, Pete,
I'll keep this question as brief as I can.
I am currently serving in the armed forces. Once my service concludes, as part of the AFPS 15 I will be given either a tax free lump sum or an early departure payment depending on when I leave and my service length.
My question is this. Will this payment count towards my lifetime pension tax free cash withdrawal figure? Essentially, will my tax free limit from my SIPP in the future be decreased by the value of this EDP/ lump sum?
The payment nor the armed forces pension doesn't come from any pension "pot", so I am unsure of whether the payment would count as tax free cash as it would if I were withdrawing from my SIPP.
Thanks gents!
Nick
31:04 Question 6
Hi both
I'm looking to retire in the next 2 years aged 60 and for the first 15 years or so (hopefully) pay zero tax by living off my personal allowance drawn from my pension, some tax free cash also taken from my pension and topped up with money held in my ISA's.
My question is………
As a non-tax payer and not earning any taxable income could I put £2880 into a SIPP each year from money held in an ISA which would then receive a £720 top up from the government which I could then withdraw as part of my tax free allowance getting the £720 for free each year? (£1440 for myself and my partner)
I understand I could only do this until age 75 but seems easy money if it's possible?
The idea came to me when I recently set up a SIPP for my son who is going to university this year so isn't a tax payer either (obviously he won't be able to draw down on the SIPP for 40 years but I can't see a reason this wouldn't work for me) Is this workable?
Thanks so much for looking at the question and hope to see it answered on a future podcast episode
Steve
More Business podcasts
Trending Business podcasts
About The Meaningful Money Personal Finance Podcast
Pete Matthew discusses and explains all aspects of your personal finances in simple, everyday language. Personal finance, investing, insurance, pensions and getting financial advice can all seem daunting, but with the right knowledge and easy-to-follow action steps, Pete will help you to get your money matters in order.
Each show is in two segments: Firstly, everything you need to KNOW, and secondly, everything you need to DO to move forward on the subject of that episode.
This podcast will appeal to listeners of MoneyBox Live, Wake Up To Money, Listen to Lucy, Which? Money and The Property Podcast.
To leave feedback or ask a question, go to http://meaningfulmoney.tv/askpete
Archived episodes can be found at http://meaningfulmoney.tv/mmpodcast
Podcast websiteListen to The Meaningful Money Personal Finance Podcast, Prof G Markets and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app
- Stations and podcasts to bookmark
- Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
- Supports Carplay & Android Auto
- Many other app features








































